Topic

Social Talk

Tags

Politicians

Author
Cinnamon Carter

Presidential Debates: A Mockery or Democratic Process?

presidential debates mockery

I recently read an editorial by Stephen Carter of Bloomberg View in the Star Ledger offering a radical suggestion for improving the debates that “are neither debates nor presidential.”  The candidates say nothing of substance and amount to nothing more than “nonsense,” both in rhetoric and nonsensical behavior (one guess as to whom takes the top prize).


Carter‘s radical suggestion is to take the “debate” out of the debates.  Give each candidate the questions in advance (perhaps 48 hours) and not allow follow-up questions except by consent of the candidate.  Give each candidate a total of 45 minutes for all responses and let them decide how much time to spend on each.


Three things could possibly happen:

  1. In reality, presidents don’t craft responses on the spot. They consult staff and outside experts. Allowing them to do the same for a debate would reveal the quality of the people around them (aides who make or break a president).
  2. Reduce “glib” responses that reward the “smooth” candidate rather than the one who is right. The ideal candidate should be thoughtful and reflective, resisting entirely the tendency to shoot from the hip. Lack of time for persuasion makes candidates state a position, but not offer serious justification for it, reducing the electoral process to slogans and applause lines resulting in candidate’s appealing to emotion alone and creating voters who go with their “gut” and not their brains.
  3. We would see what a candidates priorities are.  By having them choose how much time to spend on each question we would know what issues they consider important.  How they allocate their time might tell us more than their answers.  We could than compare the amount of time each candidate spends on a given question.


If the candidates and media won’t take control of this mockery, than the public must take to social media and demand an end to this reality show “entertainment” and demand a return to the proper decorum of the electoral process.  What is happening is an embarrassment to a country considered to be a leader of nations.  I like Mr. Carter’s suggestion.  BUT IS ANYONE LISTENING?


What do you think?


Paraphrasing and quotes from: Sunday, Star-Ledger, January 17, 2016, Perspective: Revise debate to get real answers; Stephan L. Carter/Bloomberg View

Author
Cinnamon Carter



Things That May Interest You

Similar Stories
Social Talk

Does Social Media Contribute as a Factor in Teen Suicide?

An analysis of teen suicides between 2010 and 2015 showed an increase in suicide rates at the same time that use of social media...

Social Talk

Does Giving Away Turkeys Really Help the Homeless?

The holidays were probably enjoyable for you this year but here's something you might not have thought about.

Social Talk

To Save or to Toss. That is the Question?

Anyone who is a flea market and thrift shop junkie knows how distressing it is to find all the things our generation and previous...

Social Talk

Is it Really Necessary to Live Stream Natural Disasters and Mass Shootings?

And for that matter everything else?

Social Talk

Oh, woe is me!

We have all been taught that is doesn’t help to wallow in our sorrows.  If you fall down, pick yourself up, and try again.  Feeling...

Social Talk

Human Embryo Editing: Progress or Controversy?

Details were revealed in the journal “Nature” on gene editing on human embryos conducted for the first time in the United States. ...

Social Talk

Are Low-calorie Sweeteners Really the Promised Land as Promised?

Fewer calories equates to fewer pounds.  Artificial sweeteners were given the blessing of both the American Diabetes Association and the...

Social Talk

Charging Your Batteries in a Chaotic World

Whether you follow the news, the fake news, or the very fake news, managing the stress of daily living is and is becoming more and more...

Social Talk

The World’s Need to Continue Legacies of Kindness

It has been 20 years since the tragic death of Princess Diana.  Her two sons have carried on her passion for giving and kept alive her...

Social Talk

Everything Old is New Again

Go to the attic, find that old record player, and dust off those albums!  Vinyl is making a comeback!    Sony Music stopped producing...

Things That May Interest You