Topic

Social Talk

Tags

Politicians

Author
Cinnamon Carter

Presidential Debates: A Mockery or Democratic Process?

presidential debates mockery

I recently read an editorial by Stephen Carter of Bloomberg View in the Star Ledger offering a radical suggestion for improving the debates that “are neither debates nor presidential.”  The candidates say nothing of substance and amount to nothing more than “nonsense,” both in rhetoric and nonsensical behavior (one guess as to whom takes the top prize).


Carter‘s radical suggestion is to take the “debate” out of the debates.  Give each candidate the questions in advance (perhaps 48 hours) and not allow follow-up questions except by consent of the candidate.  Give each candidate a total of 45 minutes for all responses and let them decide how much time to spend on each.


Three things could possibly happen:

  1. In reality, presidents don’t craft responses on the spot. They consult staff and outside experts. Allowing them to do the same for a debate would reveal the quality of the people around them (aides who make or break a president).
  2. Reduce “glib” responses that reward the “smooth” candidate rather than the one who is right. The ideal candidate should be thoughtful and reflective, resisting entirely the tendency to shoot from the hip. Lack of time for persuasion makes candidates state a position, but not offer serious justification for it, reducing the electoral process to slogans and applause lines resulting in candidate’s appealing to emotion alone and creating voters who go with their “gut” and not their brains.
  3. We would see what a candidates priorities are.  By having them choose how much time to spend on each question we would know what issues they consider important.  How they allocate their time might tell us more than their answers.  We could than compare the amount of time each candidate spends on a given question.


If the candidates and media won’t take control of this mockery, than the public must take to social media and demand an end to this reality show “entertainment” and demand a return to the proper decorum of the electoral process.  What is happening is an embarrassment to a country considered to be a leader of nations.  I like Mr. Carter’s suggestion.  BUT IS ANYONE LISTENING?


What do you think?


Paraphrasing and quotes from: Sunday, Star-Ledger, January 17, 2016, Perspective: Revise debate to get real answers; Stephan L. Carter/Bloomberg View

Author
Cinnamon Carter



Things That May Interest You

Similar Stories
Social Talk

How New Technology Tricks You into Forgetting Things – Losing my mind or losing my cellphone?

There was a time, long, long ago, in an era that is now far, far away, it was impossible to lose your phone.  Why, you say?  Because the...

Social Talk

Beware: Nothing in life is free

Those of us not born into the age of Facebook, Twitter, Instagram – you get the idea, have long known nothing in life is free and if...

Social Talk

The World is Still Populated and Run by Humans

So shouldn’t people in every city considering autonomous cars be asked if they want to allow them and if so, in what function?

Social Talk

Technology: To help and protect us or a brain drain?

We design technology to assist us, provide warnings for us, prevent us from getting hurt, to provide checks and balances, and even take...

Social Talk

Have you developed internet anxiety?

You are probably thinking this is about being anxious about using the internet.  Guess what, it is not (or is it?).  This is about the...

Social Talk

Is constant & continual progress necessary? When is it time to stop?

It seems that there is no final frontier.  Human kind has investigated and continues to investigate the earth, the planets, the oceans,...

Social Talk

The End of an Era: Kiddie Cathedrals

Toys R Us will soon shutter its doors forever. The last of the big toy stores where children could wander the isles in amazement at the...

Social Talk

Will Technology Eventually Take Over Your Life?

Even more than it has already.

Social Talk

Why Our Lives are Shorter Than Those in Other Wealthy Nations

Up until 1979, we could expect to live approximately 1.5 years longer than a resident of one of a group of 35 wealthy, predominantly...

Social Talk

Should Trained Teachers Carry Guns?

After Columbine, when the massacre was fresh in the country’s memory, the public cried out for better gun control.  Then the memory...

Things That May Interest You